Customer Reviews:
Highly recommended biography of our thirteenth President.......2007-09-23
I am currently reading a biography of every President in order. For Millard Fillmore the selection of Rayback's (amazon.com has spelling incrrect) one volume biography of our thirteenth President was an easy choice given the lack of alternatives and the positive reviews this book has received from other readers.
I am happy to say that I concur regarding the quality of this book. Rayback has written a comprehensive and interesting biography of Millard Fillmore that is a highly enjoyable read. Rayback get's the detail level just right and succeed's at painting a thorough portrait of Millard Fillmore's life, political career, and the times and issues in which he lived. The writing style is very readable and rarely does the book get dull.
The only criticism I have regarding this book is that it does seem to be slightly biased in favor of Fillmore and makes some assumptions regarding Fillmore's inner feelings and thoughts on certain events for which I am quite sure the author would be hard pressed to find definitive documentation. The book also portrays Fillmore as always being selfless, good intentioned and often a victim of his own magnaminity while his enemies (namely Thurlow Weed and William Seward) were motivated only by the pursuit of political power. My suspicion is the story is not quite as one sided as this but Rayback, in my opinion, does not adequately explain fully the motivations behind Weed's enmity towards Fillmore. My guess is Weed's abolitionism and sectionalism was at odds with Fillmore's more pragmatic opposition to slavery and conviction of the primacy of preserving the Union. With the hindsight of history I believe good points can be argued about both positions however Rayback defaults to Fillmore's point of view.
These criticisms aside, this is still a great biography and highly recommended.
Thoughtful & Well articulated Read.......2007-01-03
An excellent biography of a little known President. I was pleasantly surprised to find a well written and articulated biography. I think Robert Raybach, did a thorough job in his research and it shows in the detail of his writing. Millard Fillmore, is a better President then some of those who proceeded him and who immediately followed after him. His integrity was beyond reproach and he was a self made man. He was a pragmatist where as his successor treated the white house as a waffle house instead of with the same courage as Millard Fillmore. I highly recommend this biography to anyone who wishes to become more familiar with the 13th President of the United States. This biography should be in every high school and college and university across the country.
Best author I've read so far.......2006-03-14
Like many other students of history, I'm reading a biography of each president. Fillmore's life and the events of his day are laid out more clearly than any other author I've read so far. I learned (should I say 'understood') more from this reading than all the others. Highly recommended.
Fillmore--A Story of Unionism & Party Formation.......2005-04-29
This book narrates the life of Millard Fillmore through the lens of Unionism and the formation of the many political parties in which he was involved (Antimasonic, Whig, American [aka Know-Nothing]) or to which he was opposed (Liberty, Free Soil, Republican). Fillmore's dedication to the Union, especially in passing and implementing the Compromise of 1850, is well told. This book also serves to explain the rise and fall of a number of lesser known American political parties.
The book is well-written--one of the better ones, perhaps the best, in this series of American political biographies. It was one of the last written. The author relies on letters to Fillmore as one of the main sources, since his own letters are mostly missing. Generally the author is fair and balanced, although he portrays the struggle between Fillmore and Thurlow Weed rather naively as the battle between Good and Evil. He also brushes over Fillmore's willingness to allow slavery to exist as the price for preserving the Union--an opinion that was common at the start of Fillmore's career but increasingly anathema by the end of it.
The review on the dust jacket, quoted on this item's Amazon page, written by Roy Nichols, is manifestly unfair to the book and to Fillmore. The author is not nearly so naive as Nichols makes him out to be, and Fillmore, while not a great president, was not nearly the mediocrity and indecisive man as Nichols portrays him. Read the book (it's worth it) but not the dust jacket!
Dull Millard..........2005-01-14
Not so much a reappraisal of Fillmore as the first comprehensive gathering of the facts. Raybach's book is a scholarly effort, and it would be hard to criticise the concise way in which he retells the story of this unknown president. But even his best efforts cannot help the book from being dragged down by the essential blandness of its subject. Fillmore was not as good as the greatest presidents nor as bad as the worst. If you are looking for an undiscovered gem in the presidential rough best try Polk.
Customer Reviews:
The best way to learn the American presidents that I have seen.......2006-06-23
This book is the best and most fun ways to learn about the American Presidents that I have ever seen. For each president from Washington through Clinton, there is a brief caption regarding his life and accomplishments. There is also a drawing taken from a photo or portrait, a cartoon style drawing and associated play on words to aid in remembering the name and whom they succeeded. For example, the cartoon for Dwight Eisenhower shows the Eiffel Tower with eyes on it being held by a tree with eyes. The caption is "The tree-man is crawling up the side of a huge tower that has eyes on it. It must be the eyes-on-tower!" The cartoon for Harry Truman, who preceded Eisenhower, shows the tree-man.
One of the best books for learning history and social studies, I strongly recommend this book. If my children were of a suitable age, I would buy it for them.
Awesome.......2005-10-06
After one night, I knew all 43 presidents of the United States in order without looking. This book is AWESOME!!! :D
Memories Last.......2005-06-29
I had to memorize the presidents in the fourth grade. I'm in college now and I can still remember everything from this book. Not only does it work, but it's fun to look at the pictures and learn the presidents. People of all ages can learn from this book.
Best way to memorize the presidents.......2004-09-11
For years, I have tried to get my reluctant memory to soak up the list of US presidents -- even using goofy mnemonic pictures from GENERAL memory books.
That picture stuff doesn't work, I thought.
I was wrong. After a few days of browsing through the funny memory cartoons and doing the quizzes, I know the presidents cold. And so will you.
I got my child to read this book with me as it's not supposed to be a "grownup" way to study the US presidents. Baloney! It's a great memory book for readers of all ages.
Unbelievable!!!!!!!.......2004-04-01
I am in a presidential class at a Univeristy and I had to learn all the presidents for class. I checked out the book and read it and within about 20 minutes i could write all 43 presidents from memory. This is unreal it really works!!!!
Book Description
Millard Fillmore has been mocked, maligned, or, most cruelly of all, ignored by generations of historians--but no more! This unbelievable new biography finally rescues the unlucky thirteenth U.S. president from the dustbin of history and shows why a man known as a blundering, arrogant, shallow, miserable failure was really our greatest leader.
In the first fully researched portrait of Fillmore ever written, the reader can finally come face-to-face with a misunderstood genius. By meticulously extrapolating outrageous conclusions from the most banal and inconclusive of facts, The Remarkable Millard Fillmore reveals the adventures of an unjustly forgotten president. He fought at the Battle of the Alamo! He shepherded slaves to freedom on the Underground Railroad! He discovered gold in California! He wrestled with the emperor of Japan! It is a list of achievements that puts those of Washington and Lincoln completely in the shade.
Refusing to be held back by established history or recorded fact, here George Pendle paints an extraordinary portrait of an ordinary man and restores the sparkle to an unfairly tarnished reputation.
Customer Reviews:
Pendle for President!.......2007-08-07
Pull on your nightcap, drop an extra marshmallow in your cocoa and plump a fresh pillow for teddy - bedtime will never be the same again! If you crave a little excitement before your nine hours of the dreamless then I wholeheartedly recommend Pendle's hilarious romp through one of the more obscure backwaters of American history as the perfect nightcap. This is rib-tickling, tummy-tingling writing of the highest caliber - a rollicking boys-own rampage through the ludicrous life of the unlucky 13th president of the USA. You will be utterly, unutterably delighted by some of the scrapes and japes that beset Fillmore in a playful commentary that will have you wiping the tears from your eyes (tears of joy, such a refreshing change). Stop reading this review and buy it now (I said stop reading).
A sophomoric insult to real biographers and historians.......2007-07-31
This book is neither fish nor fowl: neither a real biography (it should be catalogued, shelved and marketed as "Humor" and not as Biography) nor particularly funny satire. It's really more of a sophomoric mocking of biographers and historians who conduct actual research and write compelling stories of people's lives. It's just not funny, but rather silly in a way-too-full-of-himself way. Do not waste your money.
Hard to tell where the "joke" is.......2007-07-08
As we learned with the author's poorly researched last book, he is not above making things up when it suits his theory or whim. Here, he makes the whole book up in a misguided effort to be amusing in an effete drawing room style. The truth is that the entire book would amount to a three minute Saturday Night Live sketch or maybe two pages in MAD magazine. I really don't know why you would bother with this book.
Fascinating and deeply chucklesome.......2007-06-15
George Pendle has managed literary alchemy turning a dull base president into gold. He writes so well that each sentence is a masterpiece of surrealist wordsmithery. One could be forgiven for being distracted or even dismissive of the footnotes, but they are as much part of the picture as the main text, and had me laughing out loud regularly. There are flavours of monty python ridiculousness, the flashman novels and the language skills of will self - i eagerly await this author's next offering.
Bog-lover, mystic, doofus, president.......2007-05-22
This is easily the funniest book ever written about any American president (I'm looking at you, Melville) -- and what a president. Fillmore's inspiring story provides great guidance to all Americans as we approach the 2008 presidential campaign, because surely we should be in search of a successor worthy of Pendle's Fillmore, a man blessed by fortune who nevertheless was without guile. In short, this is a great book about a great man and who the hell cares about what Thurlow Weed thought about tariffs on whale oil?
Book Description
In this book Elbert B. Smith disagrees sharply with traditional interpretations of Taylor and Fillmore, the twelfth and thirteenth presidents (from 1848 to 1853). He argues persuasively that the slaveholding Taylor--and not John C. Calhoun--was the realistic defender of southern slaveholding interests, and that Taylor did nothing to impede the Compromise of 1850. While Taylor opposed the combination of the issues into a single compromise bill that could not be passed without ammendments to suit the extremists, he would have approved the different parts of the Compromise that were ultimately passed as separate measures.
Most historians have written that Taylor's death and Fillmore's accession led to an abrupt change in presidential policy, but Smith believes that continuity predominated. Taylor wanted the controversies debated and acted upon as separate bills. Fillmore helped to accomplish this. Taylor was ready to defend New Mexico against Texas. Fillmore ordered 750 additional troops to New Mexico and announced publicly that he would do the same. Taylor had wanted statehood for California and New Mexico with self-determination on slavery. As separate measures, the Congress admitted California and preserved a viable New Mexico as a territory authorized to make its own decision on slavery.
With secessionists pitted against moderates in the southern elections of 1851, Fillmore had to choose between his constitutional oath and his personal antipathy to the new fugitive slave law. He supported the law and thereby helped keep southern moderates in power for a few more years. In fact, however, his efforts did not recapture a single slave. In Smith's view, Fillmore's most serious mistake was refusing in 1852 to get himself nominated for another term.
Smith argues that Taylor and Fillmore have been seriously misrepresented and underrated. They faced a terrible national crisis and accepted every responsibility without flinching or directing blame toward anyone else.
This book is part of the American Presidency Series.
Customer Reviews:
Two maligned presidents receive the credit due them .......2004-09-20
Of all the presidents, Millard Fillmore may have the worst public perception. There is even a group spoofing him as the most forgettable president in history. I first learned of this group when Johnny Carson mentioned it during a monologue on an episode of the Tonight Show. It is of course absolutely false; Fillmore was a strong president with deeply held beliefs who acted in the best interests of the country. While he was a New Yorker and personally despised slavery, Fillmore upheld the great compromise of 1850 and continued the policies of Zachary Taylor.
Taylor was the owner of many slaves, but all indications are that he was a very benevolent owner. He was also a pragmatist, understanding all too well that economic conditions dictated that slavery was not viable in the newly acquired western territories. Above all else, he was a unionist, stating in no uncertain terms that he would use federal troops against anyone who tried to break the union. As a former general, he was very credible when he threatened to personally lead federal troops in the potential battle between New Mexico and Texas. All through the years of the presidencies of Taylor and Fillmore, there is the clear movement towards the war that broke out ten years later.
Both men have traditionally been ranked in the bottom level of presidents, largely due to the terrible events of the civil war. Smith is absolutely right in going beyond this simplistic view and explaining the tremendous successes that both men achieved as president. The circumstances were beginning to spiral out of control and three political giants; Henry Clay, Daniel Webster and John C. Calhoun all were passing from the scene. Even in retrospect, it is hard to see how they could have done more to preserve the union. Two great tragedies that helped lead to the civil war are explained in great detail. The death of Taylor after only sixteen months in office was a disaster. If he had survived and served two terms, it is very possible that the lurch toward sectional war could have been held in check. As a southern slaveholder and a strong unionist Taylor had credibility to oppose southern secessionists that few others had. His last complete year in office would have been 1956, and the Whig party would have survived. The demise of the Whig party was the key disaster, as it led to the rise of the Republican Party, which had trivial support in the slaveholding areas. While the Whig party had enormous internal problems, the fact that they could elect southern slaveholders to the presidency demonstrates that they were a national party.
While the events that came after their term in office must be included in any historical analysis of a president, a sensible sense of perspective must be maintained. Other people rise to hold political offices and their actions have more effect on events than their predecessors do. Taylor and Fillmore have been maligned for events that were largely beyond their control. Yes, there were things that they could have done differently while in office that could have helped heal the growing sectional rifts. However, on balance their presidencies were more successful than they have traditionally been given credit for. Smith breaks with that tradition, by concentrating on what they did, he describes two men who held the rudder of state on as even a keel as was humanly possible. Those were times of great looming dangers; they fought them with great skill and determination. Unfortunately, they passed from the scene all too quickly.
Excellent.......2004-07-12
This is the fourth text I have read in the American Presidency Series, and I also rate this one a 5 star. This series provides a detailed overview of what is happening in the country socially and culturally, in addition to politically. I like that I learn not only about the two presidents ; but also, I was given details on many of the other major political figures of the time. An extensive use of primary sources is used, and the author makes an effort to discuss how previous biographers have presented each president, how the presidents have been viewed at different points in history, and how this account sees the presidents. This is a sympathetic biography of both, but the author's assessment is solidly supported with evidence. I am not a historian, just a person reading a bio of each of our past presidents. Interesting, story-telling. I did not find this work boring and dry. It also sets the stage for the Civil War and explores the issues that help build toward war.
Average customer rating:
- Millard Fillmore and the Great Compromise of 1850
|
Millard Fillmore: Our 13th President (Our Presidents)
Gerry Souter , and
Janet Souter
Manufacturer: Child's World
ProductGroup: Book
Binding: Library Binding
 Political
| Biographies
| People & Places
| Children's Books
| Subjects
| Books
U. S. Presidents & First Ladies
| Biographies
| People & Places
| Children's Books
| Subjects
| Books
General
| United States
| History & Historical Fiction
| Children's Books
| Subjects
| Books
General
| Ages 4-8
| Children's Books
| Subjects
| Books
General
| Ages 9-12
| Children's Books
| Subjects
| Books
General
| United States
| Americas
| History
| Subjects
| Books
Children's Books
| Large Print
| Formats
| Books
ASIN: 1567668380 |
Book Description
A thorough, illustrated biography discussing the president's childhood, his career, his family, and his term as President of the United States. Includes a time line and glossary.
Customer Reviews:
Millard Fillmore and the Great Compromise of 1850.......2002-04-30
You really have to appreciate the way weird things happen twice in the American Presidency. As we all know, if you father was president and you have the same first name but a different middle name, then like John Quincy Adams and George W. Bush you can become president despite getting less popular votes than your opponent. At the start of the 19th-century there was something similar, in that the two times the Whigs elected Presidents, both of whom had been famous generals, the Presidents died in office. Consequently, there were four Whig presidents, only two of whom were elected. The final Whig president was Millard Fillmore, the subject of this volume in the Our Presidents series.
In this juvenile biography by Gerry and Janet Souter, students will learn of Fillmore's difficult youth, where he was apprenticed several times. Falling in love with his slightly older teacher, Fillmore succeeded in becoming a lawyer, worthy of her hand in marriage. Involved in politics in Buffalo, Fillmore was elected to the U.S. Congress and somehow became the Whig's Vice Presidential nominee to run with Zachary Taylor. This sets up the main political drama of his life, when there was the possibility that Fillmore would have to cast the deciding vote as President of the Senate on the Great Compromise of 1850, offered up by Henry Clay. The belief was that Taylor would veto the bill if it passed, but then the President died. Consequently, it was Fillmore who signed the bill into law, basically alienating both the north and the south. Clearly, this incident was basically the only high drama of Fillmore's presidency.
This is an informative introductory biography of Fillmore, from which I learned that his wife contracted pneumonia at Franklin Pierce's inauguration and died shortly after. Detailed sidebars tell about the Antimasons, the Mexican War, and the Buffalo Historical Society. The margins of this book is filled with Interesting Facts from Fillmore's life and times (e.g., he never met Zachary Taylor until after they won the 1848 election). The book is illustrated with historic paintings, etchings, and early photographs. In terms of providing introductory information about the Presidents, this series does an excellent job.
Book Description
A hysterical new novel from the author of What's Wrong with Dorfman?Once a gangly teenager in oversized clothes, Plato G. Fussell is now handsome and independently wealthy. But inside he's still a bundle of neuroses and anxieties, with a tendency to engage in moronic word games in the presence of beautiful women.In the midst of working on his definitive ten-volume biography of Millard Fillmore, Plato finds himself dodging his vile ex-wife, trying to please his demanding elderly mother by inquiring weekly about the state of her bowels, and attempting to remain verbally coherent while courting a young woman whom he meets after her errant Frisbee connects with his cranium.As Plato blunders on in search of true love, romance, and an acceptable degree of worldwide cleanliness, he discovers that loving someone and knowing them needn't go hand-in-hand.
Customer Reviews:
A Breat Gook!!!.......2007-02-10
That's right.....a great book!!. Fun, fun....Always another surprise just jumping right up. You'll learn all about agoraphobia....I "googled" the definition and clipped it to the cover. The main character, Plato G. Fussell is unbelievable ....The first few pages may make you wonder if you need to pursue it but....just wait. You're in for a hilarious trip. Not to be missed!!!
Hilarious and quirky.......2005-04-04
This isn't your casual love story. This is a story about a slightly eccentric Plato G. Fussell, rich, handsome, and a bit obsessive-compulsive. I loved the storyline as it was rich in great detail and Blumenthal's use of puns kept me smiling throughout the entire novel. Moreover, Plato becomes such a lovable character that you don't realize how crazy he really is! I enjoyed this book because it is lighthearted, and carries a somewhat whimsical tone. It is a story that will warm your heart as it has warmed mine.
Most Interesting Psychological Romance!.......2004-12-23
After being damaged to the core by his high school sweetheart, Plato Fussell has given up on love. Between being rich and obsessive compulsive, Plato knows that finding someone that honestly loves him will be nearly impossible.
When love finds Mr. Fussell again, it is with another obsessive compulsive patient... whom he finds out just happens to be his psychiatrist soon to be ex-wife.
Once you add the health problems of his father, his mother's wild antics - this book will keep you giggling for hours.
As a nurse and romance author who worked with psychiatric patients for almost two years, it was not hard at all to picture this family and all their little quirks.
I really connected with this book also in the fact the I graduated from High School the same year as Plato Fussell. I could imagine very vividly his High School years and what was going on at the time in the world.
Mr. Blumenthal does an excellent job in portraying these serious psychological problems into a book full of hilarious antics. One of the most interesting psychological romances that I have ever read!
Wonderfully Entertaining.......2004-12-01
If Woody Allen were still making funny movies, they would be a lot like John Blumenthal's books: full of hilarity, wisdom and the quirkiest characters this side of a Tom Robbins novel.
In his latest, we meet Plato G. Fussell, a garden variety neurotic who happens to be writing the definitive 10 volume biography of America's most forgotten President, Millard Fillmore. Plato, who believes that romantic love is nothing but hogwash, has a slight problem meeting women: he tends to speak gibberish in their presence, an uncontrollable tick of some sort. He spouts spoonerisms and says names backwards. But when he happens to meet the delectable Emily Thorndyke, a woman afflicted with a whole other set of equally interesting neuroses, he can't help but fall in love with her, in spite of his dismissal of romantic love as "a monstrous flimflam perpetrated on the gullible masses by a cabal of soulless profiteers."
The book has more than a few unexpected twists and turns and kept me guessing the whole time. And the ending is a marvelously crafted surprise. But Blumenthal is more than just a simple comedy writer - his novels tell us something profound about the human condition and "Millard Fillmore, Mon Amour" is no exception.
Couldn't Put it Down.......2004-11-02
It's not easy to make me laugh aloud when I'm all by myself reading, but John Blumenthal did with his latest hilarious book, "Millard Fillmore, Mon Amour."
Between the hypochondriacal antics of Plato G. Fussell to those of his even-weirder mother, this book will keep your floor clean because you'll be rolling all over it.
My friends can always use a laugh, so I bought a bunch of copies for holiday gifts.
Average customer rating:
- So much detail, so poorly written
- Reads more like a giant pamphlet than a biography
- Millard Fillmore - Robert J. Scarry
- An Excellent and Thorough Biography
|
Millard Fillmore
Robert J. Scarry
Manufacturer: McFarland & Company
ProductGroup: Book
Binding: Hardcover
General
| Biographies & Memoirs
| Subjects
| Books
Presidents & Heads of State
| Leaders & Notable People
| Biographies & Memoirs
| Subjects
| Books
General
| United States
| Historical
| Biographies & Memoirs
| Subjects
| Books
General
| 19th Century
| United States
| Americas
| History
| Subjects
| Books
General
| United States
| Americas
| History
| Subjects
| Books
All Titles
| Qualifying Textbooks - Fall 2007
| Stores
| Books
ASIN: 0786408693 |
Book Description
From the time he left office in 1853, thirteenth United States president Millard Fillmore has become increasingly shrouded in mystery and stereotyped by traditional anecdotes that have come to be accepted as fact. The real Millard Fillmore was not the weak and boring figurehead many Americans today believe he was. This account of Fillmore's life is drawn largely from the Fillmore family's personal papers, many of which have previously been suppressed, unavailable, or believed lost for decades. Covering Fillmore's life from his ancestry to his presidency, and finally to his death and descent into obscurity, this history presents Fillmore as his own letters do, and as his friends, family members, and contemporaries saw him, as a distinguished and honorable man who was also a strong and effective president. This comprehensive work includes a genealogy of the Fillmore family, a brief chronology of Fillmore's life and career, a bibliography, and an index. Photographs complement this carefully researched portrait of a wrongfully underrated American leader
Customer Reviews:
So much detail, so poorly written.......2003-11-09
I sympathize with chefdevergue who also reviewed this incredible biography. Is McFarland & Company a vanity press? Did the editors run out of time?
First, the good news:
I have read hundreds of biographies of which about two dozen are of American presidents. I remain surprised and disappointed at the futility of my search for cradle-to-grave biographies of the less famous presidents. For example, try to find such a biography of John Tyler. So I really appreciate the comprehensive, detailed treatment of Fillmore (although the author never explains how Fillmore supported himself from the time he left the presidency until he married a rich widow). I applaud the inclusion of a timeline, genealogy, illustrations, index, notes, and bibliography.
Now to the reasons why I shook my head till it started to rattle:
How can a book this long and expensive ($75.00) escape critical editing and some semblance of a peer review? Page after page, I shook my head in amazement as I wrestled with weak sentence construction, loose paragraph structure (as chefdevergue explained in an earlier review), frequent double prepositions, improper antecedents, and the ever present Department of Redundancy Department.
Of course the author is on a mission, not to rehabilitate Fillmore to the status of at least an "average" ranking among presidents, but just to rescue Fillmore from obscurity. I wonder how poor Millard would feel about becoming well known as a result of this biography.
If you want informed political analysis to set the context for Fillmore's adult life, look elsewhere but be prepared to look far and wide. This is not scholarly work, but rather a detailed story.
Considering the dearth of alternatives for adult readers, those who are interested in learning about the life of Fillmore should put on their neck braces so they don't shake their heads too much, get comfortable, and read this book.
Reads more like a giant pamphlet than a biography.......2003-10-02
While I agree with the author that Millard Fillmore has been unjustly maligned by historians as a weak boring president, I found this biography to more of a disservice to Fillmore than anything else.
Detail in a biography is nice, but this book reads more like a giant pamphlet, with endless recitation of one tidbit after another, than a coherent, analytical biography. The paragraphs often seem to have nothing to do with each other; the author states a single fact, cites his source, and then moves on. The facts being stated sometimes seem to be more than the reader really needs:
"Fillmore wrote home about accidents. In 1838, a head-on collision of locomotives occurred on the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad which prevented a passenger train arriving with mail. In 1841, a flood on the Susquehanna River carried away a steamboat to Chesapeake Bay. A rescue boat was sent for relief." (p. 123)
What usefulness such information serves in understanding Fillmore (other than the fact that he wrote letters to his family) is beyond me. Unfortunately, the book is full of such paragraphs.
When he is not inundating the reader with minutiae, Scarry tends to sound like a character witness in Fillmore's trial. He clearly reacts personally to what he perceives as negative attacks on Fillmores character, and indignantly leaps to Fillmore's defense. Since I don't find Fillmore to be a particularly controversial historical figure, I find this passion to be somewhat misplaced. It tends to detract from a sense of objectivity on the author's part.
When all is said and done, I guess you can say that this is informative a biography on Fillmore as the reader can expect to find. Being informative does not necessarily equate with being a good biography. For example, one could read Robert Remini's biography of Daniel Webster to get a contrast on how one can write about this time period. Fillmore is important to a certain degree, but I really don't think his importance merits a biography as exhaustive as this.
This is not a terrible biography, and it does fill a void regarding Fillmore. However, the author would be well-advised to remove much of the minutiae, which would cut the book's length in half. The tedious nature of the book means many readers may lose interest halfway through.
Millard Fillmore - Robert J. Scarry.......2002-01-10
Robert Scarry was a retired history teacher and town and village historian for Moravia, New York. Scarry's own study of Fillmore spanded several decades. In this work, Mr. Scarry has probably created the definative work on our country's thirteenth president.
Robert Scarry has shown that much of what is commonly held to be true of Millard Fillmore is not. His earlier work (1965) on Fillmore was a small booklet that underwent several printings. Now, in his book, Millard Fillmore, Scarry has presented new material that stands even some of his earlier research on its head.
As a much-misunderstood figure in American history, Fillmore has both received blame for that which he should not be held to account for and not enough credit for the his overlooked or forgotten successes during his pre-civil war presidency.
Civil War period buffs and anyone intersted in the early days of our country and the presidentcy should get this book.
An Excellent and Thorough Biography.......2001-03-13
Historians have relegated Millard Fillmore to virtual obscurity. This biography, however, attempts to improve his image as a strong, effective, chief executive. The author traces Fillmore's lineage, childhood, law career, Congressional years, and presidency.
The author argues that Fillmore based his presidency on nationalism, Constitutional principles, and laissez-faire economy. Although opposed to slavery, Fillmore supported the Fugitive Slave Law as a compromise to avert Civil War. He supported the Compromise of 1850 that submitted California as a free state. To promote economic growth, he endorsed a moderate 20% tariff. He also appealed for the Transcontinental Railroad. According to the author, he strongly handled the Texas-New Mexico dispute. Fillmore advocated neutrality in foreign affairs with moderate diplomacy.
This book adroitly recognizes Millard Fillmore's accomplishments in an intelligent manner. The book has many interesting anecdotes and quotes that greatly embellish the narrative. For example, Fillmore's writings demonstrate an adherence to Constitutional principles, nationalism, and favorite foods, stand on slavery, and political ideology.
This book includes illustrations and thorough footnoting. The chronological format adds to my reading enjoyment. The appendix includes letters and notes at the end to supplement the text. An excellent bibliography gives the reader a list of books for further exploration. The book also includes a useful Millard Fillmore chronology about important dates and events. The lucid prose adds cogency in perhaps a too sympathetic biography.
Books:
- Milosevic: Portrait of a Tyrant
- Mornings on Horseback: The Story of an Extraordinary Family, a Vanished Way of Life and the Unique Child Who Became Theodore Roosevelt
- Nixon and Mao: The Week That Changed the World
- Nuremberg Diary
- October Surprise: America's Hostages in Iran and the Election of Ronald Reagan
- On Guerrilla Warfare
- One Special Summer
- Palestine: Peace Not Apartheid
- Perfect Spy: The Incredible Double Life of Pham Xuan An Time Magazine Reporter and Vietnamese Communist Agent
- Putin's Russia: Life in a Failing Democracy
Books Index
Books Home
Recommended Books
- Smart Talk for Achieving Your Potential: 5 Steps to Get You from Here to There
- Fancy Nancy and the Posh Puppy
- Viaje a la Habana
- A Historical Atlas of the Jewish People: From the Time of the Patriarchs to the Present
- Brando Unzipped: A Revisionist and Very Private Look at America's Greatest Actor
- History: Fiction or Science
- Complete Book of Cacti and Succulents
- The Home Equity Sharing Manual
- Your Stars at Work: Using the Power of Astrology to Get Alone and Get Ahead on the Job
- Glencoe Accounting First Year Course Electronic Learning Center Student Package
Zachary Taylor: Soldier, Planter, Statesman of the Old Southwest (Southern Biography)
Franklin Pierce: Young Hickory of the Granite Hills
President James Buchanan: A Biography
Old Tippecanoe: William Henry Harrison and His Time (Signature Series)
Franklin Pierce: New Hampshire's Favorite Son
